Discover
Sibie’s Pizza Menu
Welcome to Sibie’s Pizza, a hidden gem in Amherst, MA, renowned for its vibrant menu and cozy atmosphere. Located at 481 West St, this eatery is not just a place for pizza; it’s a hub for comfort food lovers. Discover a variety of mouthwatering pizzas with options to tailor your experience, including the possibility to half-and-half your toppings.
Each pizza is crafted with homemade crust, ensuring a delightful combination of fluffiness and crispiness. Customer favorites include the four-cheese pizza and their acclaimed chicken tenders, perfect for sharing or indulging solo. Beyond pizza, Sibie’s offers a range of delectable subs and stuffed breads, catering to both vegetarian and vegan diners.
With convenient services like delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, Sibie’s Pizza is truly a community favorite. Whether you’re dining with family or grabbing a quick bite, this restaurant promises quality and flavor in every dish.
Apps & Sides
Potato Skins - Plain
$7.95Potato Skins - Bacon & Cheddar
$9.45Potato Skins - Vegan
$9.95Mozzarella Sticks
$6.50Chicken Fingers with Fries
$9.95French Fries - Small
$4.50French Fries - Large
$5.95Onion Rings - Small
$4.50Onion Rings - Large
$5.95Sampler
$9.50Breadsticks
$5.50Side of Marinara
$1.00Side of Bleu Cheese
$2.00Side of Wings Sauce
$1.00Side of Dressing
$1.00Side of (V) Ranch
$2.00Deep River Potato Chips
$2.25Tossed Salad
$8.75Greek Salad
$9.25Caesar Salad
$8.75Spinach Salad
$9.00Party Size Tossed Salad
$23.00Party Size Greek Salad
$24.00(V) Greek Salad
$10.50(V) Spinach Salad
$10.50
Salads
12" Cheese or Custom Pizza
12" Cheese Pizza
$12.5012" Custom Pizza
$12.5012" (V) Combo
$19.0012" (V) Taco
$19.2512" (V) Florentine
$19.0012" (V) Southwest
$19.0012" (V) Mediterranean
$19.0012" Vegetarian
$16.5012" Mediterranean Veg
$16.5012" Spicy Bleu
$16.5012" Mexican
$16.5012" Shepherd's Pie
$16.5012" Combo
$16.5012" Ranch
$16.5012" Chicken Taco
$16.5012" Greek
$16.5012" Garden Potato
$16.5012" Basil & Tomato
$16.5012" Lauri's Favorite
$16.5012" The Supreme
$22.2012" (V) Basil Tomato
$19.00 12" Specialty Pizza
16" Cheese or Custom Pizza
16" Cheese Pizza
$16.2516" Custom Pizza
$16.25Two Large Cheese Special
$23.0016" (V) Combo
$25.2016" (V) Taco
$25.4516" (V) Florentine
$25.2016" (V) Mediterranean
$25.2016" (V) Southwest
$25.2016" Vegetarian
$23.2016" Mediterranean Veg
$23.2016" Spicy Bleu
$23.2016" Mexican
$23.2016" Shepherd's Pie
$23.2016" Combo
$23.2016" Ranch
$23.2016" Chicken Taco
$23.2016" Greek
$23.2016" Garden Potato
$23.2016" Basil & Tomato
$23.2016" Lauri's Favorite
$23.2016" The Supreme
$31.2516" (V) Basil Tomato
$25.20 16" Specialty Pizza
Vegan (ALL)
(V) Buffalo Tempeh - 5
$6.95(V) Buffalo Tempeh - 10
$11.95(V) Crispy Tofu Bites - Small
$6.75(V) Crispy Tofu Bites - Large
$10.50(V) Eggplant Parm Sub - 8"
$8.50(V) Eggplant Parm Sub - 12"
$10.20(V) Chicken Parm Sub - 8"
$8.50(V) Chicken Parm Sub - 12"
$10.20(V) Meatball Sub - 8"
$8.50(V) Meatball Sub - 12"
$10.20(V) Taco Pizza - 12"
$19.25(V) Taco Pizza - 16"
$25.45(V) Taco Pizza - Party Size
$35.45(V) Florentine Pizza - 12"
$19.00(V) Florentine Pizza - 16"
$25.20(V) Florentine Pizza - Party Size
$35.20(V) Mediterranean Pizza - 12"
$19.00(V) Mediterranean Pizza - 16"
$25.20(V) Mediterranean Pizza - Party Size
$35.20(V) Southwest Pizza - 12"
$19.00(V) Southwest Pizza - 16"
$25.20(V) Southwest Pizza - Party Size
$35.20Boneless Wings - 5 Wings
$6.95Boneless Wings - 10 Wings
$13.95Boneless Wings - 15 Wings
$17.55Boneless Wings - 20 Wings
$23.40Boneless Wings - 30 Wings
$35.10Boneless Wings - 40 Wings
$46.80Bone-In Wings - 6 Wings
$9.00Bone-In Wings - 12 Wings
$17.76Bone-In Wings - 18 Wings
$26.28Bone-In Wings - 24 Wings
$33.60Bone-In Wings - 36 Wings
$48.60 Wings
Subs
BLT Sub - Small 8"
$7.50BLT Sub - Large 12"
$9.00BLT Sub - Wrap
$8.50Chicken Parm Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Chicken Parm Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Chicken Parm Sub - Wrap
$8.50Eggplant Parm Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Eggplant Parm Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Eggplant Parm Sub - Wrap
$8.50Ham & Cheese Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Ham & Cheese Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Ham & Cheese Sub - Wrap
$8.50Hot Sausage Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Hot Sausage Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Hot Sausage Sub - Wrap
$8.50Italian Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Italian Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Italian Sub - Wrap
$8.50Meatball Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Meatball Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Meatball Sub - Wrap
$8.50Turkey Sub - Small 8"
$7.50Turkey Sub - Large 12"
$9.00Turkey Sub - Wrap
$8.50Buffalo Chicken Sub - Small 8"
$8.20Buffalo Chicken Sub - Large 12"
$9.50Buffalo Chicken Sub - Wrap
$8.50Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub - Small 8"
$8.20Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub - Large 12"
$9.50Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub - Wrap
$8.50Chicken Caesar Sub - Small 8"
$8.20Chicken Caesar Sub - Large 12"
$9.50Chicken Caesar Sub - Wrap
$8.50Chicken Pesto Sub - Small 8"
$8.20Chicken Pesto Sub - Large 12"
$9.50Chicken Pesto Sub - Wrap
$8.50Tuna Lovers Sub - Small 8"
$8.70Tuna Lovers Sub - Large 12"
$9.75Tuna Lovers Sub - Wrap
$9.00Broccoli & Cheddar Stuffed Bread
$5.95Ham & Cheese Stuffed Bread
$5.95Pepperoni Stuffed Bread
$5.95Choose 1 Topping Stuffed Bread
$5.95 Stuffed Breads
Calzones
Plain Cheese Calzone
$8.75Specialty Calzones
$11.00Create Your Own Calzone
$9.00Create Two Calzones
$16.50Jumbo Calzone
$16.45Cheese Party Pizza
$24.50Custom Party Pizza
$24.50 Party Size Cheese/Custom Pizza
Party Size Specialty Pizza
Party (V) Combo
$35.20Party (V) Taco
$35.45Party (V) Florentine
$35.20Party (V) Mediterranean
$35.20Party (V) Southwest
$35.20Party Vegetarian
$32.70Party Mediterranean Veg
$32.70Party Spicy Bleu
$32.70Party Mexican
$32.70Party Shepherd's Pie
$32.70Party Combo
$32.70Party Ranch
$32.70Party Chicken Taco
$32.70Party Greek
$32.70Party Garden Potato
$32.70Party Basil & Tomato
$32.70Party Supreme
$43.70Party (V) Basil Tomato
$35.2010" GF Cheese Pizza
$10.7510" GF Custom Pizza
$10.75 Gluten Free Pizza
Dessert (The Sweet Stuff)
Maple Valley Ice Cream (1 Pint)
$6.00Maple Valley Ice Cream (2 Pints)
$11.0012 oz. Cans
$1.7520 oz. Bottles
$2.752 Liter Soda
$3.25