Hello dear
Welcome to Sibie’s Pizza
At Sibie’s Pizza, we believe great pizza brings people together. Nestled in Amherst, Massachusetts, our story is rooted in passion for high-quality ingredients and memorable flavors. For over 18 years, we've delighted locals with our homemade crust and diverse menu, which offers everything from specialty pizzas like the Chicken Taco to vegan and vegetarian options. Our cozy, divey atmosphere is perfect for families and groups, complemented by outdoor seating and a welcoming vibe. With delivery, takeout, and catering available, we aim to create enjoyable experiences. Join us to savor the taste that keeps our community coming back for more!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bone-In Wings - 36 Wings
Boneless Wings - 40 Wings
Party Supreme
Party (V) Taco
About
Sibie’s Pizza
Welcome to Sibie’s Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Amherst, Massachusetts. Located at 481 West St, this beloved establishment has captivated pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike with its extensive menu and warm, welcoming ambiance.
Sibie’s Pizza is more than just a pizza joint; it's a destination for food lovers. Whether you opt for their classic 16” Cheese Pizza or customize your own pie with a variety of fresh toppings, each pizza promises a delightful experience. Customers rave about the homemade crust that strikes the perfect balance between fluffy and thin, ensuring every bite is a treat.
- Exceptional Offerings: Beyond pizza, the menu includes delicious chicken wings and an array of subs, like the popular BLT and Chicken Parmesan options. The versatility of Sibie’s makes it great for group gatherings, offering everything from individual slices to large party pizzas.
- Inclusivity and Accessibility: Sibie’s takes pride in being accommodating. With vegan and vegetarian options available, as well as wheelchair accessibility and outdoor seating, everyone can enjoy a meal here. Families will also appreciate the kid-friendly choices and catering services for larger events.
- Consistent Quality: Customers have shared their love for the high-quality ingredients and consistently delicious pies. Regulars like Dan K. have been enjoying Sibie’s for 18 years, praising the establishment for maintaining exceptional standards and affordability.
- Community Feel: The atmosphere at Sibie’s is described as divey yet quiet, making it an ideal spot to unwind with friends or family. With on-site parking, waiter service, Wi-Fi, and even a TV for entertainment, it’s a holistic dining experience.
What sets Sibie’s Pizza apart is more than just their food; it’s their dedication to crafting memorable dining experiences while serving the community. As you sink your teeth into their renowned pizza or savor their chicken tender appetizer—often considered a grown-up favorite—you'll understand why Sibie's is a staple in the Amherst area.
To sum it up, Sibie’s Pizza is a must-visit for anyone in search of quality pizza, superb customer service, and a relaxed atmosphere. Whether you're grabbing takeout or settling in for a meal, the inviting spirit of Sibie’s will leave you wanting to come back for more.
For inquiries or orders, feel free to call them at (413) 256-6100 and experience the pizza magic for yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I've been getting pizza from this place for 18 years. This place quietly has the best pizza and calzones in Amherst--I've tried 'em all.. They take note of their ingredients, and the crust is homemade. Weirdly consistent -- and pleasantly affordable. Takeout or delivery. ”
“ Pizza and subs are always high quality and quite delicious. One of my favorite pizza places. Also love the veggie burger bomb. ”
“ Stopped at Sibbies pizza for a take out pizza. I'd had their grinders previously (which are great) so it was time to try the pizza. One of the things I like about this spot is that it's possible to 1/2 a pizza one way, and the other half another. I ordered a medium with 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 combination. The pizza was great! The crust was cooked well and fluffy on the sides while the bottom the pizza crust was thin, I'll definitely be back. ”
“ Surprisingly the most outstanding item on the menu is the chicken tender appetizer which was for the kids but stolen by the grownups, and the 4 cheese pizza is delicious. The other pizzas are ok enough . ”
“ Omg they have the best dairy free cheese... best local pizza around. They use follow your heart cheese. It looks and taste like real cheese... ”
“ Pretty darn good! I went here with my roommate and ordered their pepperoni/jalapeno/feta pizza, she got bbq chicken. Diverse set of toppings offered and cool options like vegan/whole wheat/gluten-free. ”
“ Great vegan pizza!!! They have four vegan pizzas to choose from as well as Italian-American classic sandwiches like a "chicken Parm" or "meatball" sub. It's sadly not an eat-in restaurant, but it's a great pickup or delivery option!!! ”
“ This place is great! We stopped in after a visit to the Eric Carle Museum (only 2 miles away) after researching places in the area with vegan options. Sibie's did not disappoint! They have your standard pizza, sub, and wrap selection for anyone who eats meat or dairy, but their vegan options are also great! I had the buffalo tempeh app and the chick'n parm (made with Gardein)--both so good! And my husband enjoyed the jalapeño poppers and buffalo chicken wrap. I contemplated making camp and hanging out until I was hungry again so I could order the vegan meatball sub, use their non-dairy cheese and meatless options to craft the perfect vegan pizza, or choose from their speciality pizzas--there's a vegan Florentine, Mediterranean, Taco, and Southwest pizza! Yum! So suffice it to say, although it's an hour away, we'll be back! One point to note: this isn't a sit-down restaurant--the website does specify that they offer carryout, delivery, and catering, but even so, we wanted to eat there before our drive home. We were able to make it work since it was a nice day and there are two picnic tables outside, but that's definitely something to keep in mind! ”
